BMCR 2016.11.32
.
" ... as a whole the volume testifies amply to Welch’s
skill and experience as an editor. The contributions are well selected
and there is abundant evidence of cross-fertilization and quality
control: typos and errors are few and inconsequential. The index
is full and the consolidated bibliography invaluable, although using
the latter with endnotes (after every article) is cumbersome. The
book is well laid out and pleasingly sturdy. It also contains several
excellent maps. It is an altogether exemplary volume. " Adam Kemezis
Classics for All, 10 May 2016.
"
This must be one of the most substantial books on Roman republican
history to have appeared in the last decade. ... This is a collection
of serious and demanding scholarship, produced to a very high standard
(the indexes are excellent), and it does not have much to offer to
the lay reader. However, its range means that it will have something
meaningful to offer to a very diverse audience of classicists." Federico
Santagelo, |